Hereford 1972: the goal that stopped English football

On 5 February 1972, on a mud heap of a pitch in the city of Hereford, a club that was not even in the Football League knocked Newcastle United out of the FA Cup. The match had already been postponed three times, and the goal that changed everything was scored by a carpenter. Fifty years on it is still the image people reach for when anybody says the word upset.

Five postponements before it could be played

It was a third-round tie and it began at St James' Park on Monday 24 January, in front of 39,301. Hereford went ahead after seventeen seconds through Brian Owen; Malcolm Macdonald and John Tudor turned it around inside thirteen minutes, and Colin Addison — who was both player and manager — equalised with a shot from twenty-five yards. 2-2, and a replay.

The replay took some getting to. The first tie had already been postponed twice for rain, and the return at Edgar Street was called off three more times. By the time it was finally played, on Saturday 5 February, the pitch was a bog and the third round was running weeks behind the rest of the competition.

It is worth grasping the distance between the two clubs. Hereford played in the Southern League, outside the Football League altogether, and Newcastle were a First Division side with a squad full of internationals. No non-league club had beaten top-flight opposition in England since Yeovil beat Sunderland in 1949.

Three minutes

The match reached the 82nd minute goalless, and then Macdonald headed in a deep Viv Busby cross. Newcastle 1-0 up, eight minutes left, and the tie looked settled exactly as everyone had assumed it would be.

In the 85th, Ricky George won the ball on the left, the clearance dropped short and Ronnie Radford got there before John Tudor. He played a one-two with Brian Owen, and the return bobbled back to him off the mud. It sat up kindly. Radford hit it first time from somewhere between thirty and thirty-five yards — the distance depends on who is telling it — and it flew into the top corner.

In extra time, in the 103rd minute, Radford found Dudley Tyler on the right, Tyler pulled it back, and Ricky George — on as a substitute — turned away from Bobby Moncur's challenge and drove it across the keeper. A non-league club had just knocked out Newcastle.

The twenty-six-year-old with the microphone

The BBC had sent a young commentator to Edgar Street, twenty-six years old and on trial. His name was John Motson and he had been given a short highlights piece, because nobody expected anything from this match: the weekend's real stories were the fourth-round ties. When Radford scored, the game became the feature match on Match of the Day.

Motson went on to be the voice of English football for forty years, and he always said that muddy afternoon was what made his career. He died in 2023.

The two celebrations supplied the other half of the picture: hundreds of boys in parkas pouring onto the pitch, and spectators up in the trees and on the floodlight pylons because there was no room left inside. Radford's goal won Goal of the Season and stayed in the Match of the Day opening titles for years.

What happened next

In the fourth round Hereford drew 0-0 with West Ham at home and lost the replay 3-1 at Upton Park, where Geoff Hurst scored a hat-trick. That match kicked off on a Monday afternoon: it was the winter of the miners' strike and power restrictions meant the floodlights could not be used.

There is one more number worth pausing on. Hereford were the first non-league club to knock a top-flight side out of the FA Cup since Yeovil beat Sunderland in 1949 — a gap of twenty-three years. In the half-century since, plenty of lower-division clubs have produced upsets, but a genuinely non-league side beating a First Division or Premier League club has stayed vanishingly rare, which is why a muddy replay in 1972 is still the reference point.

That summer, on 2 June 1972, Hereford were elected into the Football League in place of Barrow. The first ballot finished level at 26 apiece and had to be run again. And in their first season as a League club they went up, finishing runners-up in the Fourth Division.

The ending is harsher. Hereford United were wound up by the High Court in December 2014 after a petition from the tax authorities. Four days before that ruling their supporters had already founded Hereford FC, which kept Edgar Street, the Bulls nickname and the black-and-white kit, and started again in the fifth tier of non-league football. It won three promotions in a row, the last of them with 113 points.

"Ronnie Radford was a carpenter. His shot has spent half a century being the definition of what a cup can do."

• Simulate the whole FA Cup and decide who reaches Wembley.
• Engineer your own giant-killing and watch the bracket rearrange.
• See how often the favourites survive a third round.
• Share your finished bracket as an image once you have it.

"Open the FA Cup simulator and go looking for your own Hereford."